provincial_currency_c772df8b-05a1-4418-bdcc-aec5b9579898
overlay

The Money That Makes Us

Before our Confederation in 1867, the currencies of our early nation’s landscape was a hodge-podge of tokens, promissory notes, and privately minted coins. But, in the lead up to Confederation and the introduction of decimal coinage, the provinces of Newfoundland, Prince Edward Island and Nova Scotia were minting early versions
of their own currencies to be used in their growing economies. These early provincial currencies tell a
compelling story of Canada’s numismatic and economic history.

So let’s look at some of the provincial currencies produced way back when.
Newfoundland
In the first few decades of the 19th century, the British government was trying to figure out how to manage this new budding nation and its economy from overseas. There had been a plan in place to bring Sterling into the colonies, but this was abandoned in Newfoundland in 1838. What were the people of Newfoundland to do? Sponsored European settlements had been there for over 150 years and fishing was a main source of income and an economic driving force for the area. So, to fill this gap and satisfy the economic needs of the community, a token was issued by a pair of merchants called the Rutherford brothers. Initially circulating in the 1840s, the Rutherford halfpenny token featured the Rutherford coat of arms on the obverse, and a hanging sheep beneath their names on the reverse (Figure 1).
token-1860-fishery-rights-half-penny-g_copy
   Figure 1: Both sides of the Rutherford Tokens. Numista.

By the 1860s, Newfoundland’s coinage took on a more political tone and was used as a form of protest. For years, the coastal waters of the province had been fought over by the English and the French. Since Newfoundland was a British colony, this made it more difficult for fishermen to have control over the waters, their product, and its processing. Also at this time was the desire for responsible government and free trade. To establish their desire for these limits and governance, a token was issued by the Heaton Mint stating this fact (Figure 2). 
token-1860-fishery-rights-half-penny-g
Figure 2. 1860 Fishery Rights for Newfoundland token. Coins and Canada.

Finally, in 1863 Newfoundland began its journey to introducing decimal coinage in the territory. They remained independent until 1949, when they joined Canadian confederation, and continued circulating their own currency until then as well. 
Prince Edward Island
One of the earliest coins traded in the colony of Prince Edward Island were Spanish-American dollars. However, in the summer of 1813 when Governor General Charles Douglass Smith arrived to take up his position, he found that there was a crisis of currency scarcity in the province. His solution was to take the Spanish-American dollars and punch holes out of them, creating what was called “holey dollars” and dumps (Figure 3). From then on, the dump (the piece punched out of the larger dollar) would be worth a shilling and the “holey dollar”, five shillings.
206-03-origins-holey
Figure 3. An example of a Spanish colonial coin mutilated into a “holey” dollar and its dump.
The holey dollars and dumps continued to be used until 1815. However, throughout the rest of the first half of the nineteenth century, Prince Edward Island experienced rapid economic growth which led to a boom in population. Because of this, a social hierarchy was created which allowed a class of merchants to monopolize the industrial landscape of the colony. They needed to make money and fast. So a group of nine merchants came together and brought a bill forth to the Legislative Assembly proposing a chartered bank on the island.
After much back and forth between the politicians in Britain and the merchants at home, the bill was passed and the Bank of Prince Edward Island opened its doors in the summer of 1856.
The Bank of Prince Edward Island was prosperous for many years, until it fell into the cunning hands of some new cashiers who began making large cash advances under false pretences. Unfortunately the bank filed for bankruptcy in 1881 and was forced to liquidate all their assets. Today, it is rare to find a bank note from the Bank of PEI, though not impossible. See some examples in our collection here:
1_cab28faf-e6d6-4a52-a31b-7667e5b05790
Rare $1 note from 1877
2_f526b67f-e57c-4891-88f0-707d09859aaf
Rare $2 note from 1877
3
$10 note with a cutting error
Nova Scotia
 Scotiabank, one of the world’s leading financial institutions hosts over 25 million clients across the globe in the present. However, this bank wasn’t always a powerhouse. In fact, the Bank of Nova Scotia has fairly humble beginnings that can be traced back to the founding of Halifax in 1749. Similar to Prince Edward Island, the colony of Nova Scotia faced quite the issue when it came to the attempts to introduce British sterling currency into its economy. Between 1749 and 1823, there were strides made to streamline the circulation of certain types of currency that eventually resulted in the introduction of the thistle tokens. 
On the obverse of these coins was the face of the monarch, and the reverse, “a handsome thistle”, as requested by the colonial treasurer during the initial phases of minting (Figure 4). 
token-1860-fishery-rights-half-penny-g_copy_7515572f-5659-49df-8a2a-2b1501b139b9
Figure 4: An 1823 thistle half-penny token featuring the bust of King George IV on the obverse.
Adding a thistle to the coin was an interesting nod to the Scottish heritage beginning to grow in the colony. Certain breeds of the thistle plant are native to Scotland and would have served as a reminder of the old country that many inhabitants handling these coins would have come from. 
Just like its Maritime neighbor though, Nova Scotia began to see both its population and its economy boom. There had been a private bank called the Halifax Banking Company that was unable to obtain a charter from the Nova Scotia Legislative Assembly, so the Bank of Nova Scotia was chartered by a separate group of merchants to fill the growing need for a public bank (Figure 5). 
Scotiabank_original_opening_image
Figure 5: Water colour of the John Romans' Building located at the corner of Granville & Duke streets in Halifax, where The Bank of Nova Scotia opened for business on 29 August 1832, its first location.
Opening in 1832, the Bank of Nova Scotia quickly became a financial leader in Canada and abroad. Bank of Nova Scotia notes are a valuable piece of Canada’s numismatic history and they continued to be minted by the Bank until the charter of the central Bank of Canada in 1935. 
See some of our examples here:
4_4f3e88ac-0ccf-4e1c-98dc-23383f17863f
1908 $5 note
5
1925 $20 note
Canada’s numismatic history has taken on many forms and is thanks in part to the diverse histories of its communities across the land. Some of these currencies, like that from the Bank of Nova Scotia, are relevant
in the current day, though others are more obsolete.
No matter where they are from though, Canada’s pre-decimal provincial currencies allow both numismatists
and historians alike a keen insight into the economic and social histories of the provinces of Canada in the
lead up to Confederation. 
Baker, Melvin. History of Newfoundland and Labrador Summary Chronology of Events (PDF), 2003. https://www.gov.nl.ca/publicat/royalcomm/research/bakerchronology.pdf.
Baldwin, Douglas O. “The Growth and Decline of Charlottetown Banks, 1854-1906.” Acadiensis, Spring 1986, 15, no. 2 (1986): 28–52.
Chapados-Girard, C, ed. A Charlton Standard Catalogue: Canadian Colonial Tokens. 11th ed. The Charlton Press, 2023.
“Corporate Profile.” Commercial Business Banking. Accessed November 18, 2026. https://gtb.scotiabank.com/content/scotiabank/ca/en/about/inside-scotiabank/corporate-profile.html.
Graham, R J, ed. A Charlton Standard Catalogue: Canadian Bank Notes. 10th ed. The Charlton Press, 2023.
“The Scotiabank Story.” Scotiabank Global Site. https://www.scotiabank.com/ca/en/about/our-company/archives/our-exhibits/the-scotiabank-story.html.